Shelter Harbor Inn

The Inn is charming, but we stayed in the basement of the carriage house which is dark, cold and damp. The bed was uncomfortable. We will visit again because the property's nice, the staff is friendly, and the location is good. However, we will make sure we stay in the Inn next time.

Expected more for the price of this property. The heat went out and they did not fix it until the morning. It was a cold night and the staff didn’t seem concerned that we had a terribly cold night. The breakfast was basic. Will definitely not be returning.

Didn’t like that it was extremely noisy until 3 a.m. and that in the morning no one was at the desk so that I could tell them about it. I did call when I got home, but think that they could have been more sympathetic and understanding. I do understand that they said I should have called when it was happening but I didn’t realize that they have someone on call all night as this was our first visit there and we were not in the main house. We were in the barn, which I might add is lovely, and they did say that the main house and a small house that is between the main house and the barn is much quieter. Unfortunately that was not known by us either. I really think that they could’ve at least offered us a discounted rate for a future visit. Very poor public relations.

This is a beautiful Inn. The beds are very comfortable! We loved our room with a balcony and fireplace, we will definitely be back. ❤️

The staff and service were lovely. And the restaurant attached to the inn is excellent. However, for the cost, the room was tiny, oddly decorated, and had a very uncomfortable bed and pillows. The TV was placed in a spot that was hard to see for one of us because of the bed posts. And the bathroom was extremely tiny, with virtually nowhere to put any toiletries. The shower stall had black tile and no lighting so it was very dark. The very thin walls of the room made it so that you heard everything going on in the other rooms. Lastly, the continental breakfast felt skimpy considering the cost per night.

The inn was excellent except for the lighting in room 1. It was so dark it was like a cave even during the day. The bedside lamps were so low they were useless for reading. No one should be put in that room until the lighting is improved.

Very pretty grounds and building. Comfortable and clean. Great location to visit East Beach and Watch Hill. Unfortunately restaurant is closed Mondays and Tuesdays so can not rate. There was a tavern 2 min. down the road so that wasn't a big deal. The continental breakfast was nice to have to start the day. We went during perfect summer weather but I'm sure this Inn is lovely anytime of the year!

This Inn has been delightfully updated. Staff is very helpful and friendly. Very clean great restaurant.

The photos on line don’t do this place justice. The inn is lovely, the restaurant was delicious and I found the staff lovely and very helpful. Would love to stay there again, and will definitely recommend to friends.